Research page
CCDP

Young Venezuelan Migrants in Colombia’s Urban Peripheries: Criminals, Criminalized or Change-Makers?

Photo credit (banner): Elena Butti

Project description 

 

In recent years, the humanitarian crisis in Venezuela has led to a massive inflow of Venezuelan
migrants into neighbouring Colombia. In the absence of proper reception facilities, the vast
majority of these migrants resettle in urban peripheries – spaces largely controlled by criminal
gangs, where the most disadvantaged sectors of the Colombian population live. This two-year
project (2023–2025), funded by the SNSF, seeks to ethnographically explore the experiences of
these migrants, and specifically their relationship with the criminal groups that operate in the
areas where they settle.


Following an initial round of fieldwork, the project is focusing more specifically on these
migrants’ access to informal housing. Based on several months of immersive ethnography
conducted by Dr Butti on the outskirts of Medellín, in one of Latin America’s largest informal
settlements, the project highlights the growing role played by criminal gangs in the illegal land
and housing market that has emerged within these settlements. Initial findings reveal that, as
part of a broader strategy to diversify their income streams, criminal gangs in Medellín have
started to take a more active role in this illegal housing market, essentially commercialising what
used to be an organic occupation process. The occupation, plotting, and construction on private
land in the city’s outskirts – previously a collective process spontaneously performed by
occupying residents – has been increasingly co-opted by criminal gangs, who now play a
central role in managing and profiting from this informal housing market. Venezuelan migrants
are among the most frequent customers of this market, contributing to the rapid expansion of
the city’s informal margins.


Using Gago and Mezzadra’s (2017) notion of ‘urban extractivism’ (see also García Jerez, 2019),
this project shows that gang-controlled informal housing markets represent both the neoliberal
capture of decades of popular self-organisation and the gangs’ own way of benefitting from the
migration crisis.


The project is hosted at the Centre on Conflict, Development and Peacebuilding of the IHEID, in
collaboration with the Universidad Nacional de Colombia.


Associated projects can be found on www.elenabutti.com

KEY EVENTS OF THE PROJECT

 

Dr Butti has conducted two immersive fieldwork rounds (March–June 2024; February–March
2025), through which she has gained good access to the neighbourhood, built relationships of
trust with several Venezuelan families, and observed changes in the land and housing market
over time. As part of her action research, Dr Butti has also produced a short ethnographic film
on the realities of the neighbourhood and organised a crowdfunding campaign.


Featured film: El Sueño de la Casa Propia (The Dream of Owning a Home, 2025): a micro-
documentary project showcasing the efforts of a young Venezuelan migrant family to build their
own home on the outskirts of Medellín, Colombia.

El sueño de la casa propia - Short documentary by Elena Butti

Dr Butti also delivered two keynote addresses (Fundación Paz Ciudadana and the European Association of Social Anthropologists Early-Career Keynote) and gave two invited seminars (Geneva Graduate Institute and London School of Economics). She also presented at seven conferences, including the Global Initiative on Transnational Organized Crime, the EASA Biennial, the SLAS Annual Meeting, and the LASA Annual Meeting. She has also organised two conferences: South–South Migration: The Venezuelan Case and Beyond (Universidad Nacional de Colombia) and Juvenicide: Conceptualising, Measuring, Preventing, and Countering Systematic Violence Against Young People (Universitat Pompeu Fabra – with externally secured funding from the Wenner-Gren Foundation).
 

Featured conference: Dr. Butti is currently organizing a workshop on this topic, titled Housing, Illegality and Criminal Actors, to be held on 9-10 September 2025 in Geneva. 

Email [email protected] if you’d like to attend.

In 2024, Dr Butti has also been a Visiting Professor at the Faculty of Human and Economic Sciences of the National University of Colombia in Medellín, as well as a Visiting Researcher at the Department of Communications of the Universitat Pompeu Fabra. She has moreover continued serving as Secretary General of the Société Suisse des Américanistes (SSA). Finally, she has co-founded the Colectivo Juvenicidio y Resistencias Sociales (JUVIR), dedicated to the study of youth assassinations in the Latin America region.

Key Publications:


Butti, E. [forthcoming]. We Are the Nobodies: Youth, gangs, and precarity in neoliberal
Colombia. Ethnographic monograph under contract in the Anthropology List of New York
University Press.
 

Feixa, C., Bonvillani, A., Butti, E., and Muñoz, G. (eds.) [forthcoming]. Juvenicidios, Violencias
y Resistencias Sociales. Commissioned by NED Ediciones.

Butti, E., Van Damme, E. and Ziosi, E. [forthcoming]. Gangs and organized crime in Latin
America: Boundaries, intersections, and articulations. In Eurogang edited volume, eds. D.
Carson, M. Urbanik and R. Shanon. London: Springer.
 

Butti, E. 2025. Youth are not all the same: On the appropriateness and limits of participatory
methods when studying youth in contexts of marginalization. Social Sciences, Special
Issue Researching Youth on the Move: Methods, Ethics and Emotions, eds. N. Hansen and C.
Feixa.
 

Butti, E. (2024). Safe and Ethical Ethnography: Looking Inwards. In Inclusive Ethnography:
Making fieldwork safer, healthier and more ethical, eds. C. Procter and B. Spector, pp. 18-32.
London: SAGE.